The All-MLB Free Agency Team

February is right around the corner. Winter is almost on its way out, and pitchers and catchers start to report to spring training in just 2 weeks. The MLB landscape, though, is far from set.

It’s no secret: there are some excellent players still left on the free-agent market. Bryce Harper and Manny Machado have gotten most of the press, and rightfully so; they’re the types of generational talents that you’d think teams would be lining up to pay on the first day of free agency. But they’re not the only ones left – you could probably field a whole team with the players still without a contract.

Not only could you field a whole team, but you could field a pretty good one. I’ve compiled a 25-man roster using only free agents, and pulled their projected 2019 statistics courtesy of Fangraphs. Take a look at this potential lineup (yes, Bryce bats 2nd):

OBP SLG WAR
1 Marwin Gonzalez LF .327 .427 1.8
2 Bryce Harper RF .399 .528 4.9
3 Manny Machado SS .356 .529 5.0
4 Mike Moustakas 3B .317 .475 2.8
5 Evan Gattis DH .305 .463 0.4
6 Adam Jones CF .307 .430 1.2
7 Josh Harrison 1B .310 .393 1.2
8 Matt Wieters C .311 .389 1.3
9 Jose Iglesias 2B .308 .372 1.7

1-9 are legitimate MLB starters. As a matter of fact, the “Free Agents” would be one of only 10 MLB teams projected to have a player with at least 4.9 WAR, and they’d have 2 in Harper and Machado.

Image result for mike moustakas brewers

For the 2nd consecutive offseason, Mike Moustakas is having a rough go of it in the free-agent market, despite borderline-All Star production.

Even their bench looks more than solid:

OBP SLG WAR
Carlos Gonzalez OF .314 .435 1.3
Carlos Gomez OF .303 .385 0.2
Yangervis Solarte IF .314 .420 0.7
Adeiny Hechavarria IF .291 .361 0.3
Martin Maldonado C .286 .362 1.0

A stable of tough southpaws make up what would probably be an average-to-below-average starting 5:

FIP WAR
1 Dallas Keuchel LHP 3.76 3.3
2 Brett Anderson LHP 4.13 1.3
3 Wade Miley LHP 4.47 1.1
4 Clay Buchholz RHP 4.73 1.0
5 Gio Gonzalez LHP 4.44 0.8

Image result for dallas keuchel

Dallas Keuchel hasn’t been talked about as much as Bryce Harper or Manny Machado, but the unsigned pitcher projects as a legitimate ace and is just 31 years old.

Even the bullpen would have some well-known names, including a championship closer:

LOB% WAR
Craig Kimbrel RHP 78.4 2.1
Ryan Madson RHP 72.9 0.1
Tony Sipp LHP 74.1 0.1
Homer Bailey RHP 69.9 0.0
Tyler Clippard RHP 73.4 0.0
Jerry Blevins LHP 73.1 0.0

The bullpen would probably look even better if I included other free-agent starters that didn’t make my top 5, like Francisco Liriano and Doug Fister.

Looking at this team got me thinking – would they make the playoffs?

I looked at Fangraphs’ projected team records for the season – there are usual suspects, like the Red Sox winning the AL East with 97 wins and the Astros taking the AL West with 95.  Their weakest projected playoff team is the Tampa Bay Rays, who are sitting at 85 projected wins. Could our free agents beat them?

To find out, I charted projected WAR by position for each of our “teams”, starting with the position players:

Screen Shot 2019-01-30 at 9.01.50 PM.png

It’s easy to see Harper and Machado stick out from the pack. Even excluding them, though, the proverbial playing field seems pretty even across positions.

Screen Shot 2019-01-30 at 9.05.04 PM.png

Again, our free agents look like they can hold their own. Carlos Gonzalez is a huge asset as a lefty off the pine, and Martin Maldonado’s glove as a defensive replacement would be among the best in baseball.

Screen Shot 2019-01-30 at 9.03.31 PM.png

For the first time, the Rays seem to have a clear advantage. That’s nothing to cry about, though – Tampa Bay ranked second in the entire American League last season in team ERA.

Screen Shot 2019-01-30 at 9.06.44 PM.png

Overall, the Rays have a far deeper ‘pen, but Craig Kimbrel is a trump card Tampa Bay can’t match in the late innings.

Going by total WAR, the Rays amassed 31.3, and our Free Agents 33.6. Of course, projected umbrella statistics are far from an end-all be-all, but they give you a pretty good idea on where this free agent team stands in terms of relative player value. That we’re coming up on February and an entire playoff team doesn’t have a job is concerning for baseball. How concerning? I don’t think anyone needs to start yelling strike just yet; last year, Yu Darvish didn’t get signed until February 10; J.D. Martinez February 19th. However, if this thought experiment is any indication, plenty of teams still have plenty of work to do. There are 30 baseball teams vying for 10 playoff spots (only 6 non-Wild Card spots), and they need to convince their fans they’re doing everything they can to make one of those 10. With each week that goes by, and each legitimate starter remaining on their couch, each fan begins to ask more and more questions.


by Derek Reifer, Northwestern University

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s